Rev. Richard G. Smith, Pastor, 9/2011 - present
Rev. David E. Nolan, Pastor, 8/2005 - 2011, Became pastor of St. Joseph of the Holy Family, NYC
Rev. Joseph Bisignano, Pastor, 1/2004-7/2005, Became pastor of St. Patrick’s in Yorktown Heights.

Rev. Tomas Bobadilla, 2001 – 2006. 
Transferred to the larger Spanish Apostolate in Newburgh, NY.
Returned to his native Mexico
Rev. John C. Lynch, Parochial Vicar, 5/2003-12/2005.
Became Pastor of St. Mary/St. Andrew in Ellenville.
Rev. Paul Awowole, Diocese of Ondo, Nigeria, summer help, 2004, 2005 and 2006. 
Currently pastor of St. Mary’s ProCathedral in Ilesa, Osun State, Nigeria.
Rev. Joseph Iyamah, Diocese of Auchi, Nigeria, summer help, 2006, 2007, 2014
Teaching in the regional seminary in Nigeria.
Rev. Sebastian Mapillaparambil, V.C., Parochial Vicar, 1/2006-11/2006
Returned to his order’s motherhouse in India.
Rev. Richard Enegbuma, Diocese of Auchi, Nigeria, Parochial Vicar, 3/2006 – 3/2007.
Returned to Nigeria where he is pastor of St. Phillip Church in Jattu-Uzairua. 
Rev. Fabian Eghiabumhe, Diocese of Auchi, Nigeria Parochial Vicar, 12/2006-2014
Returned to Nigeria
Rev. Irenaeus Ikhane, Diocese of Auchi, Nigeria, Parochial Vicar, 12/2006-2017, Returned to Nigeria
Rev. Charles Nasamu, Diocese of Auchi, Nigeria, Parochial Vicar, 6/2007 - 2008
Rev. Callistus Ihkane, Diocese of Auchi, Nigeria, summer help, 2013 & 2014
Rev. Wenceslaus Rodrigues, Diocese of New York, Parochial Vicar, 2016-2018, currently serving at Holy Child Church, Staten Island